Chapter 5 - The Girl He Carried Through the Smoke
Isaiah cried when Camille asked about Ada Monroe.
He did not cry loudly. He stared at a red paper cup of hospital coffee until tears fell into it, and then he asked for a napkin as if the spill were the embarrassing part.
“Was she the girl in the fire?” Camille asked.
He nodded.
“Why was her name in Brent's office?”
“Because they never stopped looking for her.”
Camille pulled her chair closer. “Tell me what you can. You can stop when you need to.”
Isaiah folded his hands. Their knuckles were enlarged from years of manual work. He looked at the window before he began.
In December 1998, Open Hearth was a boardinghouse with six rooms upstairs and a community kitchen below. Ruth cooked two nights a week. Joseph handled maintenance. Isaiah managed the books and sometimes drove tenants to early shifts when buses failed to arrive. A local charity covered part of the rent for people who couldn't pay.
Lionel Kessler arrived offering bigger donations and a renovation loan.
“He talked about dignity,” Isaiah said. “That word came out of his mouth every time he wanted us to give up something.”
At first the payments were real. Then Isaiah noticed charges for eight residents in a house licensed for six rooms. Reimbursements for boilers that had never been purchased. Rental assistance paid on behalf of people who had moved out months earlier.
He copied invoices and found signatures that did not belong to their signers. He was going to take the material to Joseph and a lawyer after Christmas.
“Why didn't you?” Camille asked.
“I tried.”
On Christmas Eve, someone cut the electricity. Isaiah smelled smoke near the pantry. He found Ada, eight years old, hiding in the upstairs hallway with a red mitten pulled over one hand. Her mother, a night-shift nurse, had stepped out to fetch medicine for a tenant and was due back any minute.
Isaiah carried Ada down the back stairs and pushed open the rear door. As they reached the alley, a man grabbed his collar and demanded the copied books. Isaiah recognized the voice: Arthur Harker, a security contractor who worked for Kessler.
“Brent's father?” Camille asked.
“Yes.”
Arthur struck Isaiah and searched his coat. When he found nothing, he showed him a photograph of Camille getting off the bus outside her college dormitory.
“They knew your route,” Isaiah whispered. “They knew Mama walked home from church alone.”
He said Arthur ordered him to leave Chicago, abandon the books, and never contact his family. The threat was specific enough that Isaiah believed it. He climbed into a delivery truck arranged by a family acquaintance and was driven across state lines. His injuries were treated at a clinic in Indiana, where he gave a false name.
“Why didn't you call me once you were safe?” Camille asked.
Isaiah stared at her. “I was never sure you were safe.”
“Twenty-eight years?”
His gaze dropped. “For too many of them, I let fear do the deciding. Then shame. And when I finally tried to come back, I couldn't get anyone to believe who I was.”
He told her about eighteen years working in Ohio warehouses and seasonal construction. He had kept a small apartment and sent one postcard to Ruth. After an injury, he lost steady work. The shelter he used closed, and his identification was stolen along with the coat that held his last photographs. A church volunteer eventually helped him travel back to Chicago when he heard Grace Street had been marked for redevelopment.
“I wasn't hiding for all twenty-eight years,” he admitted. “Not from you. The last few, I just couldn't find a way home that didn't start with explaining why I stayed gone.”
Camille felt anger and love fighting for the same space in her chest. “You can explain more tomorrow. Today you eat.”
He nodded, grateful and ashamed.
She called Ada Monroe through a number Dana found in a professional directory. Ada was now Dr. Ada Monroe-Larkin, a thirty-six-year-old school counselor in Milwaukee. She listened without speaking while Camille introduced herself.
When Camille said Isaiah was alive, the silence lasted nearly a minute.
“He got me out,” Ada finally whispered. “I remember his hands. He cut them opening the back gate.”
“Would you talk with investigators?”
“Yes. But I need you to understand something. I was a child. I didn't see who started the fire.”
“That's okay. Tell them only what you remember.”
Ada paused. “I saw someone leave with a metal breadbox.”
Isaiah sat up when Camille repeated it.
“Joseph's breadbox?” he asked.
“Did it hold the books?”
“A copy. I hid the original invoices inside.”
The old Open Hearth lot was fenced off, its building demolished after the fire. But a utility entrance beneath the rear steps had survived, later buried when the lot was leveled. Isaiah had once shown Joseph the compartment where he kept emergency cash for tenants.
“I remember Dad counting the rent money twice,” Camille said. “He would put aside envelopes for tenants who had been laid off, then pretend he'd made an accounting error so nobody felt embarrassed taking help.”
Isaiah smiled sadly. “He wasn't fooling anybody. Mrs. Washington sent us a peach cobbler every time he did it.”
Camille thought about a fund designed to help neighbors surviving on too little and the people who had apparently transformed it into a way to claim their houses. The betrayal was no longer an abstract number in a bank ledger. It had the smell of her father's kitchen and the faces of people who had sat at their table.
“Your mama still have that brass pantry key?” Isaiah asked.
“Yes.”
“That's not only a pantry key.”
Camille nearly smiled. Ruth had saved it for twenty-eight years without knowing it might unlock the evidence.
Dana refused to let anyone dig without permission. She contacted the trust's counsel and arranged a supervised inspection through the proper channels. The permit dispute over Ruth's home made the location urgent, but urgency would not turn evidence into something unusable.
Before leaving, Ada sent Camille a photograph of the red mitten she had kept from the night of the fire. Sewn into its cuff was an old laundry tag:
OPEN HEARTH — ROOM 8.
Camille stared. Isaiah had just told her the house had six rooms.
She showed him the image.
“There wasn't a Room Eight,” he said.
“Then why did a little girl's mitten have that label?”
May you like
Isaiah looked as though a door inside his memory had opened.
“Because they weren't counting bedrooms,” he whispered. “They were counting children.”
