Chapter 4 - The Secret Garden
I used to believe the worst thing that could happen to a person was
losing control of her own life. By the time this part of the story
began, I understood there was something worse: discovering that the
choices you thought were yours had been arranged by people who loved
you, feared for you, lied to you, or needed something from you.
That knowledge did not make me obedient. It made me curious.
Niko would later tell me curiosity was my most dangerous habit.
“Not my temper?” I asked.
“Close second.”
“Good. I’d hate to become predictable.”
His mouth would twitch whenever I said things like that, as if he were
fighting a smile he did not believe a Santoro was supposed to have.
Those tiny moments mattered because everything around us seemed designed
to turn people into roles—criminal, politician, daughter, wife, heir. I
was beginning to understand that refusing the role was sometimes the
only freedom available.
Evelyn, Niko, Mateo, and Stella enter Arthur’s townhouse and recover The
Secret Garden.
The room seemed to hold its breath after that. I watched faces rather
than words, because words had become cheap in our families. Niko’s jaw
tightened whenever he was hiding fear. Arthur looked toward doors when
he was preparing a lie. Stella made jokes when she wanted to cry. I had
habits too: I crossed my arms when I felt cornered and became
unnaturally polite when I was furious.
“Say what you’re thinking,” Niko said.
“You first.”
“That isn’t how questions work.”
“It is in this marriage.”
For a second, neither of us moved. Then the tension loosened by a
fraction. We were learning to negotiate truth the way other newlyweds
negotiated closet space.
Hidden inside are a brass key and a note in Evelyn’s late mother
Caroline’s handwriting directing Evelyn to locker 417 at Grand Central
and telling her to trust the person who knows why thunderstorms frighten
her.
I forced myself to slow down and separate evidence from emotion. Law
school had taught me that facts did not become more reliable merely
because they confirmed what I already feared. That principle was much
harder to follow when the evidence involved my parents, my husband, or a
dead person who had inconveniently stopped being dead.
“What do we actually know?” I asked.
It became my favorite question.
Not what do we suspect. Not what did somebody tell us. Not what would
make the cleanest story.
What do we know?
In a world built from secrets, that distinction repeatedly kept us
alive.
The locker contains an encrypted drive and an old photograph of Arthur,
Caroline, and Vittorio Santoro.
The room seemed to hold its breath after that. I watched faces rather
than words, because words had become cheap in our families. Niko’s jaw
tightened whenever he was hiding fear. Arthur looked toward doors when
he was preparing a lie. Stella made jokes when she wanted to cry. I had
habits too: I crossed my arms when I felt cornered and became
unnaturally polite when I was furious.
“Say what you’re thinking,” Niko said.
“You first.”
“That isn’t how questions work.”
“It is in this marriage.”
For a second, neither of us moved. Then the tension loosened by a
fraction. We were learning to negotiate truth the way other newlyweds
negotiated closet space.
A gray-haired stranger named Daniel Mercer appears and identifies
himself as Caroline’s former attorney.
I forced myself to slow down and separate evidence from emotion. Law
school had taught me that facts did not become more reliable merely
because they confirmed what I already feared. That principle was much
harder to follow when the evidence involved my parents, my husband, or a
dead person who had inconveniently stopped being dead.
“What do we actually know?” I asked.
It became my favorite question.
Not what do we suspect. Not what did somebody tell us. Not what would
make the cleanest story.
What do we know?
In a world built from secrets, that distinction repeatedly kept us
alive.
He claims Caroline’s fatal car crash was not an accident but a Janus
assassination.
The room seemed to hold its breath after that. I watched faces rather
than words, because words had become cheap in our families. Niko’s jaw
tightened whenever he was hiding fear. Arthur looked toward doors when
he was preparing a lie. Stella made jokes when she wanted to cry. I had
habits too: I crossed my arms when I felt cornered and became
unnaturally polite when I was furious.
“Say what you’re thinking,” Niko said.
“You first.”
“That isn’t how questions work.”
“It is in this marriage.”
For a second, neither of us moved. Then the tension loosened by a
fraction. We were learning to negotiate truth the way other newlyweds
negotiated closet space.
He also says Caroline’s most important evidence was a ledger and that
Evelyn already possesses the key to it: a silver locket Caroline gave
her on their last morning together.
I forced myself to slow down and separate evidence from emotion. Law
school had taught me that facts did not become more reliable merely
because they confirmed what I already feared. That principle was much
harder to follow when the evidence involved my parents, my husband, or a
dead person who had inconveniently stopped being dead.
“What do we actually know?” I asked.
It became my favorite question.
Not what do we suspect. Not what did somebody tell us. Not what would
make the cleanest story.
What do we know?
In a world built from secrets, that distinction repeatedly kept us
alive.
Evelyn remembers the locket is at her apartment.
The room seemed to hold its breath after that. I watched faces rather
than words, because words had become cheap in our families. Niko’s jaw
tightened whenever he was hiding fear. Arthur looked toward doors when
he was preparing a lie. Stella made jokes when she wanted to cry. I had
habits too: I crossed my arms when I felt cornered and became
unnaturally polite when I was furious.
“Say what you’re thinking,” Niko said.
“You first.”
“That isn’t how questions work.”
“It is in this marriage.”
For a second, neither of us moved. Then the tension loosened by a
fraction. We were learning to negotiate truth the way other newlyweds
negotiated closet space.
Then Mercer reveals the Santoros knew about the locket before the
wedding.
I forced myself to slow down and separate evidence from emotion. Law
school had taught me that facts did not become more reliable merely
because they confirmed what I already feared. That principle was much
harder to follow when the evidence involved my parents, my husband, or a
dead person who had inconveniently stopped being dead.
“What do we actually know?” I asked.
It became my favorite question.
Not what do we suspect. Not what did somebody tell us. Not what would
make the cleanest story.
What do we know?
In a world built from secrets, that distinction repeatedly kept us
alive.
Niko admits the marriage originally gave him access to search for it.
The room seemed to hold its breath after that. I watched faces rather
than words, because words had become cheap in our families. Niko’s jaw
tightened whenever he was hiding fear. Arthur looked toward doors when
he was preparing a lie. Stella made jokes when she wanted to cry. I had
habits too: I crossed my arms when I felt cornered and became
unnaturally polite when I was furious.
“Say what you’re thinking,” Niko said.
“You first.”
“That isn’t how questions work.”
“It is in this marriage.”
For a second, neither of us moved. Then the tension loosened by a
fraction. We were learning to negotiate truth the way other newlyweds
negotiated closet space.
Later, when I tried to remember that day, I would not remember the
expensive rooms or the armed men first. I would remember the moment I
realized fear had stopped making my decisions for me.
That did not mean I was fearless. I was afraid constantly.
I was afraid Niko would become the man the newspapers said he was. I was
afraid my father’s love would always arrive disguised as control. I was
afraid every recovered truth would reveal another lie underneath it.
Most of all, I was afraid that surviving these people would require
becoming like them.
Niko seemed to read the thought on my face.
“You’re doing it again,” he said.
“What?”
“Trying to carry the entire disaster by yourself.”
“I’m very talented.”
“I’ve noticed.”
I looked at him. “You don’t get to decide for me.”
“I know.”
The answer came without hesitation.
That was why, despite everything, I stayed beside him.
Our wedding had been an order. Whatever came after it had to be a
choice.
And when the next revelation arrived, it did not knock politely. It came
May you like
like every important truth in our families—late, dangerous, and carrying
proof that the story we had just accepted was already incomplete.
